It’s 2007, before teen audiences would learn that Kristen Stewart was to be their Bella Swan. There’s so much acclaim for her tiny role in Sean Penn’s Into the Wild, you’d be forgiven for thinking the former child actress was being prepped for major stardom.
While Twilight made Stewart an object of fascination, it also made her a fixture on Hollywood’s Most Hated lists. Now, she’s the ‘Best of her Generation’ — as Olivier Assayas described her after directing her to a César (the first American to win the French Oscar) for her role as an assistant to a neurotic actress in Clouds of Sils Maria.
Assayas would write Personal Shopper with Stewart in mind to star as…Maureen, a young expat in Paris. Once again, she’s cast as a celeb flunky, running around upscale boutiques for her spoiled supermodel employer, Kyra.
But Maureen is more than an underling; she’s a psychic medium, in limbo in the French capital mourning her twin brother, who died from a heart defect she shares. The film opens with her alone at night in his eerie mansion, trying to reach him on the other side.
The angry spirits that appear to Maureen seem terrifyingly real. Stewart is so believable when she mumbles about the challenges of finding portals to the other side, she’d make a decent living as a psychic if she left showbiz. From that truthful base, she even makes the name ‘Maureen’ plausible for expectant parents in the 21st century.
When she’s harassed by text messages, we question whether she’s at the mercy of something more sinister than a fashionista; have ghosts made the jump-scare to the digital era, or has she got a stalker? Or is this all in her head?
Viewers have come up with some overly-intricate theories, confused by the way the script decides to glide from supernatural, psychological horror to whodunnit.
In the final scene, Maureen encounters a ghost trying to communicate with her. She says it is one knock for yes, two for no. She asks the ghost if it’s Lewis, and it seems to confirm that it is. She asks if it’s at peace, and the answer is ambiguous. Then she asks if it’s in her head. It knocks for yes.
Perhaps the best way to understand it would be to refer to this Dumbledore gem: “Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?”
Moody, intriguing, stylish, Personal Shopper is quietly clever – a slight film that open ups with eerie insight on re-watch.
4 thoughts on “Personal Shopper review – Kristen Stewart as a stylish psychic”
Odd, but incredibly compelling. Nice review.
Many thanks Dan!
It’s sometimes truly strange to see how certain celebraties can be hated on at one moment, and loved in the next. I haven’t yet seen this film, but seen a few reviews for it, abd it certainly has my interest. As always, terrific review, and if you celebrate it: Happy Halloween to you too 😀