The live-action Ghost in the Shell is a box office dud then, and there are people who are really happy about that. Not necessarily because they are die-hard fans of the original Japanese manga and anime, but because of so-called “whitewashing”.
To some, this movie was actually an “opportunity” to cast a hitherto largely unknown Japanese or Asian-American actress, instead of a big Hollywood star. But Paramount hired Scarlett Johansson, the Tony Award-winning actress who looks good in a catsuit.
Her character is Mira, or Major. Created by the shadowy Hanka Robotics, her brain is housed in a fully cybernetic body. People have all kinds of cutting-edge enhancements, like X-ray vision, but Mira is the first of her kind and the future of humanity.
As an agent of an elite government task force called Section 9, she is dispatched across a grimy, futuristic city to fight criminals like the mysterious hacker Kuze. (Forget whitewashing ‘cos the robot workforce is coming to take everyone’s jobs.)
Very mature themes and concepts were posed by the cult 1995 anime movie, but this 12A (or PG-13) remake
really struggles doesn’t much bother with questions like: “What is it to be human in a technologically advanced society?”
Ghost is essentially a dark, stylish actioner that doesn’t get too philosophical. As with director Rupert Sanders’ debut movie Snow White and the Huntsman, it’s remarkable for its dazzling visuals and sounds.
The performances match the spectacle, with Pilou Asbæk as Major’s second in command, Takeshi ‘Beat’ Kitano as their boss, Juliette Binoche as the scientist Dr Oulet, and Michael Pitt as the villain. Johansson, for her part, has onscreen appeal and proven action prowess. She might not be able to open a $100 million movie, but she can carry one.
This isn’t a kitschy fun film, like her 2014 sci-fi hit Lucy. It isn’t as famous a property as other recent blockbuster releases, like ‘Kong‘ or ‘Beauty and the Beast‘, and it just didn’t capture the public imagination. Ultimately, Ghost seemed doomed to fail.
Still, it isn’t the travesty that the 46% Rotten Tomatoes rating suggests. (The casting negativity may have had a discouraging effect on critics.) Yes, the story needed more work, but the soundtrack, the cool visuals, and the acting make it a solid three out of five stars.
4 thoughts on “Ghost in the Shell – film review”
I’m so glad I’ve finally read a review about this film that isn’t saying how dreadful it is. I definitely agree that critics have probably been discouraged somewhat.
I could not agree with you more. It is nice to see that there are luckily some people out there that do not comdemn the movie, but appreciate it for it what it is 😊 Great review as always! 😀
Thank you! 🙂
Well put! It isn’t a masterpiece, but it’s not exactly a disaster either. I wasn’t that bothered by the casting of ScarJo as Major too.
Then again, I remember Rinko Kikuchi was a popular casting choice amongst the fans. I think she would have shone in this role!